COVID-19 or Influenza - How to Tell

Print version of this article

Background

  • COVID-19 infections are widespread in most communities.
  • During the winter, influenza (flu) infections also become widespread.
  • Here is some advice on what to do when both viruses are in town.
  • Updated: June 20, 2022 (Version 19).

COVID-19 and Flu - How They are Similar

  • Presenting Symptoms. They are nearly the same. You will not be able to tell them apart when you are sick.
    • Fever and cough are the most common symptoms for both.
    • Other respiratory symptoms such as sore throat and runny nose are common for both.
    • Muscle aches and feeling very tired are seen with both.
    • The only helpful symptom is loss of taste or smell. It points to COVID-19, but it only occurs in 15% of COVID-19 patients.
  • Viral Tests. Tests are available for both viruses. Both are done with nose or throat swabs. Testing is the only way to tell the right diagnosis. It's the only way to know for sure what someone has.
  • Types of Complications. These are nearly the same. The most common serious symptom is trouble breathing (shortness of breath). It usually means the patient has developed pneumonia. Other complications in young children are croup or wheezing (tight breathing). They are due to a child's smaller airway and can occur with either virus. The rate of complications is higher with COVID-19, especially for people who are not vaccinated.
  • High-Risk Factors for Complications. The most common high-risk factors are older age (elderly), weak immune system (from illness or medicines), lung disease, heart disease, diabetes and obesity. The CDC's high-risk patient list for the flu is similar to the list for patients with COVID-19.
  • How it Spreads. Both are spread person-to-person by respiratory droplets. Droplets are produced by coughing, sneezing, shouting or singing. They get inhaled by a nearby person or quickly fall to the floor or ground. COVID-19 is more contagious than flu.
  • Infections without Symptoms. Both infections can occur without causing any symptoms (asymptomatic people). These people can spread the disease to others. But, spread by people with no symptoms happens at a much lower rate than for people with symptoms. This is one reason why wearing masks can be helpful.
  • Home Treatment. It's the same for both viruses. Treat the symptoms that bother you the most. Provide symptom relief as needed for the cough, sore throat and fever. Drink extra fluids and stay well-hydrated. When tired, get extra rest. See the COVID-19 Diagnosed or Suspected topic for details.
  • Prevention. Getting the vaccines and booster shots can help prevent both diseases. Wearing face masks and social distancing have been proven to help prevent both diseases.

COVID-19 and Flu - How They Differ

  • Anti-viral and Monoclonal Antibody Medicines. Flu: prescription anti-virals given by mouth (such as Tamiflu) are readily available for the flu. They are mainly prescribed for sick patients who are high-risk for complications. Healthy people don't need anti-viral medication if they get flu. COVID-19: prescription anti-viral medicines are now available (such as Paxlovid). Anti-virals must be used early in the course of illness to work best. Monoclonal antibodies given for treatment and even prevention have been developed for those at high risk of COVID-19 complications.
  • Home Quarantine for Exposed People without Symptoms. The CDC recommends quarantine after close contact with someone who has COVID-19 for those who are NOT vaccinated or have not had a COVID infection. This is usually for 5 days. People who are fully vaccinated do not need to quarantine. Influenza: After close contact with someone who has flu, staying home is not recommended, unless symptoms occur. Home quarantine means avoiding other people.
  • Home Isolation for Sick People with Symptoms. Home isolation for COVID-19 is required for 5 days or longer. Vaccine status does not change this requirement. Home isolation for flu is only recommended until the fever has been gone for at least 24 hours. Reason: COVID-19 is still more dangerous than flu.
  • How Soon Symptoms Occur after Exposure. The incubation period is how many days after close contact with a sick person the symptoms start. Flu starts faster. Flu symptoms start on the average 2 or 3 days after exposure to a sick person. COVID-19 symptoms start on the average 3 to 5 days after exposure. However, the variants do have different incubation periods. The Omicron variant appears to have a 2-4 day incubation period, more like flu.
  • Time of Year. The flu is seasonal, usually October to April. It peaks December through February. COVID-19 is not seasonal at this time, but many experts feel that it will become a winter virus like flu.
  • Severity and Death Rate. COVID-19 is more dangerous than flu. It still has a higher complication rate and ICU admission rate than flu.

Care Advice

Overview:

  • Do everything in your power not to get either of these infections.
  • Getting both infections at the same time could cause more severe complications.
  • Getting them close together is also risky. The first one could weaken your body for when the second one starts.
  • Become an expert on prevention. Trust the science.
  • Here is some advice to help you get through this flu season.

Influenza Vaccine - Be Smart and Get Your Flu Shot:

  • Getting your annual flu shot is the best way to protect your family from flu.
  • These next few years are more important than ever. Reason: getting COVID-19 while you also have the flu or are recovering from it may increase the chances of getting severe complications.
  • Flu vaccines are strongly advised for all children greater than 6 months of age (AAP).
  • All adults and children should get a flu shot, not just those at higher risk for complications.
  • Most often, the flu shot prevents getting any flu infection. If the vaccine does not cover a new flu virus and you get it, the shot still helps to reduce your symptoms.
  • Getting the flu shot will turn on and rev up your immune system. Research shows that it might even reduce your chances of getting COVID-19.

COVID-19 Vaccine - Get Your COVID-19 Shot and a Booster:

  • Vaccines have saved more lives than any other public health action. They are the most powerful weapon we have against deadly infectious diseases. Follow the science.
  • Safe and effective vaccines are now available for people age 6 months and older. The CDC suggests everyone age 5 years and older should also get a COVID-19 booster, when eligible. Here is a link to the CDC booster tool: CDC booster shots.
  • Get your COVID-19 vaccine and a booster when recommended. It could save your life and protect your family.
  • Vaccine Sites: find a nearby vaccine site at vaccines.gov or call your doctor’s office.

Protect Your Family from Catching COVID-19 and Flu:

  • Face masks. Wear a well-fitting mask when you are in public indoor settings during the times of outbreaks in your community. Face masks reduce the spread of both infections. Even after you get the vaccine, face masks offer additional protection.
  • Wash your hands often with soap and water. Always wash before eating.
  • Use an alcohol-based hand sanitizer, if water is not available. Note: soap and water work even better.
  • Don't touch your eyes, nose or mouth unless your hands are clean. Germs on your hands can get into your body this way.
  • Try to avoid contact with sick people.
  • Social (Safe) Distancing. During times of outbreaks, try to stay at least 6 feet (2 meters) away from anyone who is sick. Avoid crowds because you can't tell who might be sick.

Copyright 2000-2022 Schmitt Pediatric Guidelines LLC.

Is Your Child Sick?®

Office Hours

Pediatric Healthcare Unlimited https://pediatrichealthcareunlimited.com/getattachment/00000000-0000-0000-0000-000000000000/Pediatric-Healthcare-Unlimited.aspx
Poison Control: 800-222-1222